The leaves are turning red, the nights are growing colder and my thoughts are all about Halloween, pumpkins and chestnuts, so I’m starting the seasonal sweet reviews with this autumnal dessert. I was surprised upon picking it up by how heavy it was, there is a considerable volume and weight to this product, despite it only costing around 300, so it looked set to be good value for money. Presentation-wise it’s a little half-hearted but at the use of real pumpkin chunks was promising.
Opening the lid I noticed that there was virtually no scent, only a strangely clean, almost soapy smell from the whipped cream topping. The cream is very light and airy – like the spongy marshmallow center of a Tunnock’s Tea Cake, but not as sweet – and melts instantly on the tongue. The smattering of cooked pumpkin cubes on top have quite a solid texture and I liked that the skin had been left on, as this provided a denseness and savouriness to compliment the fluffy cream. The little dollop of brown sugar jelly had a slightly burnt creme-caramel aftertaste, which, like the pumpkin, helped to balance out the sweet and airy whipped layer.
The consistency of the vanilla pudding beneath is like a cross between mousse and pudding: not quite aerated but fairly light. The mixture is appetisingly speckled with vanilla beans which give it a good flavour and aroma which comes through once the cream is gone. Separating this from the pumpkin-flavoured base is a thin, gloopy layer of brown sugar jelly. While I’m sure this must be the same concoction as the shiny dark goop atop the cream, I was disappointed to find that it seemed to have none of the same bitter burnt-sugar notes and was actually rather bland, any taste completely smothered by the sweetness of the pudding layers.
Finally, the all important pumpkin pudding. This is firmer and less sugary than the vanilla, and there is almost a mild graininess to it, like a thick fruit puree. The flavour is difficult to pinpoint – it’s pleasant and a sweet taste of artificial pumpkin is detectable but there’s no hint of a natural vegetable taste, which I would have welcomed after all the whip and vanilla.
I think Pumkpin Pudding was certainly worth its price, especially as it lasted me nearly an hour, but the proportions were completely out. The topping, with its combination of flavours and textures, was satisfying, but as I worked my way to the bottom I began to find the innocuous sugariness of the deep pudding layers a little sickly. More real pumpkin flesh, more flavourful sugar jelly and perhaps the introduction of a crunchy element could really improve this. Nice, but once was enough for me.
6/10
Family Mart Cafe Sweets Pumpkin – ¥298 345kcals